Air Fryer Halloween Quesadillas are so easy and fun to make! These can be made in the shape of jack o'lanterns, ghosts, haunted houses, or whatever Halloween shapes you want.
Place 2 tortillas on top of each other so that you can cut out your Halloween shape.
Cut out the outline of your shape using a sharp knife or cookie cutters.
If making a jack o'lantern, cut out the face. on one of the tortillas.
Arrange your cheese so that the bottom tortilla is mostly covered and as the cheese melts, it will properly cover the tortilla.
Place the top tortilla on the cheese.
Add the uncooked quesadillas to the air fryer basket. Place something on top to hold the top tortilla in place.
Air fry for 3-5 minutes at 380 degrees F, then remove from the air fryer and enjoy.
Notes
You can either cut the quesadillas into shapes using a sharp knife (like I did), or if you're making smaller quesadillas, a cookie cutter works perfectly!
Definitely use something to weigh down your top tortilla in the air fryer so it doesn't fly off! Something that is heat-safe for the air fryer. I used a rack from my Instant Pot.
I didn't spray my quesadillas with cooking spray or brush them with oil. However, if you are wanting a crispier quesadilla, you can use oil.